How Comments Work
When your mentor reviews your journal:- They read your entry (market analysis, trade reasoning, emotional state)
- They click Add Comment on the entry
- They write their feedback using the rich text editor
- You receive a notification that feedback is available
Viewing Mentor Comments
Comments appear directly below each journal entry:- Mentor comments are visually distinct (highlighted border)
- Your replies appear nested under mentor comments
- Timestamps show when each comment was added
Replying to Feedback
You can reply to any mentor comment:- Click Reply under the mentor’s comment
- Write your response
- Click Post Reply
Types of Mentor Feedback
Effective mentors typically comment on:Trade Execution
Entry timing, stop placement, target selection, trade management decisions
Emotional Patterns
Identifying emotional triggers, FOMO trades, revenge trading patterns
Setup Quality
Whether the trade matched your playbook, A+ vs B setup selection
Process Improvement
Suggestions for refining your trading process and rules
Getting the Most from Feedback
Be honest in your journal — The more detail you provide about your reasoning and emotions, the better feedback your mentor can give.
Ask specific questions — End journal entries with questions for your mentor: “Was my stop too tight?” or “Should I have held longer?”
Review regularly — Check for new comments at least weekly and respond promptly to keep the dialogue active.
Implement suggestions — Track mentor suggestions and note when you apply them in future entries.
Comment Notifications
When your mentor adds a comment:- A notification appears in your notification bell
- The journal entry is marked with a “New Comment” indicator
- (Optional) Email notifications can be enabled in settings
Best Practices for Mentees
| Do | Don’t |
|---|---|
| Write detailed journal entries | Write one-line summaries |
| Include screenshots of charts | Assume mentor knows the context |
| Be honest about emotions | Hide mistakes or losses |
| Ask for specific feedback | Expect mentor to do all the work |
| Respond to comments | Ignore feedback |